An extensive swedish study from the Sahlgrenska Academy has established that surgery reduces premature death in patients with severe obesity. A long-term follow up has shown that mortality is significantly lower among patients who undergo surgery than among those who do not.
The results are published today in The New England Journal of Medicine.
“We show for the first time that surgery against obesity not only leads to long-term loss of weight, it also significantly reduces mortality”, says Lars Sjöström, professor emeritus at the Sahlgrenska Academy, located in Göteborg in Sweden.
Over 4,000 severely obese patients were included in the study, which Lars Sjöström started as long ago as 1987. Half of these patients underwent stomach surgery (bariatric surgery) intended to give weight loss. The remaining patients received advice concerning changes in lifestyle, also intended to give weight loss. Some of these patients also received medicines for weight loss, but even so, the conventional treatment was considerably less effective than the surgical procedure.
“The group receiving conventional treatment had even increased somewhat in weight after 10 years, while patients who had undergone surgery decreased in weight by 16%, on average. Bariatric surgery is the only treatment for severe obesity for which there is scientific evidence that it reduces mortality”, says Lena Carlsson, professor at the Sahlgrenska Academy.
A long-term follow up for between 5 and 18 years of the patients who had undergone surgery showed that mortality among these patients was 29% lower than it was among the other patients.
“The mechanisms behind the lower mortality are not clear. It seems that the reduction in risk depends less upon the actual loss of weight itself than on the fact that the patients have undergone surgery against obesity. This observation opens new possibilities for discovering previously unknown mechanisms behind the increase in risk associated with obesity, and thus opens the possibility of developing new treatments”, says Lars Sjöström.
The researchers also considered the effects of many biochemical and other variables in the analysis, including smoking, stress and previous medical history.
3 thoughts on “Surgery for severe obesity saves lives”
Although now officially confirmed, the results of this study are no surprise. Obesity goes hand in hand with a number of health problems. If you reduce obesity, you will eliminate a host of potentially serious health problems such as high blood pressure, diabetes, heart disease, stroke, cancer, and fatty liver disease.
Although this study did have a control group of obese patients who did not recieve the surgery, what it is lacking is a control group of non-obese people who did and did not recieve the surgery, to see if there is any negative consequences of the treatment. At least that’s the way it seems to me.
Actually, the results are quite a surprise. It’s one of the more dangerous surgeries perfromed, although numbers are improving. Moreover, the lifestyle changes that go along with it(such as eating much more frequently, and particular foods, to prevent nutritional defeciency) present their own risks. While certainly an option for some morbidly obese, I’d still claim that cutting someone open and cutting on their stomach is very drastic and risk prone approach to mere ‘weight loss’, a case where the cure is worse than the disease.